Caltrans Features Guide - 210 vs 2010ECL vs 2018ECL vs 2018KCL Signal Monitors
Basic Functionality
- Number of Channels
- Definition: The number of signal channels the monitor can track simultaneously. Each channel typically has a Green, Yellow, and Red field input.
- 210: 16 channels
- 2010ECL: 16 channels
- 2018ECL: 18 channels
- 2018KCL: 18 channels
- Compatibility
- Definition: Compliance with industry standards and controller types.
- 210: Compliant with Caltrans TEES (Traffic Equipment Electrical Specifications).
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Compliant with Caltrans TEES and supports 170 and 2070 Advanced Traffic Controllers.
- Conflict Monitoring
- Definition: Detects simultaneous conflicting Green or Yellow signal indications assigned as incompatible.
- All models: Supported.
- 24VDC Power Monitoring
- Definition: Monitors the 24VDC power supply in the traffic cabinet to detect voltage drops or failures.
- All models: Supported.
- Watchdog Timer (WDT) Monitoring
- Definition: Monitors the controller watchdog timer to detect if the controller stops executing commands correctly. The monitor enters fault mode if a logic transition is not detected in the specified time.
- All models: Supported.
Hardware Features
- Microprocessor-Based Design
- Definition: Uses microprocessors to perform real-time monitoring and diagnostics.
- 210: Single microprocessor.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Dual microprocessors for improved fault detection and processing speed.
- Non-Volatile Fault Memory
- Definition: Stores fault status and event logs even during a power failure.
- All models: Supported.
- RMS Signal Detection
- Definition: Uses Root Mean Square (RMS) measurement to accurately detect AC signal voltage levels, reducing sensitivity to frequency and wave distortions.
- All models: Supported.
- Firmware Upgradability
- Definition: Allows firmware updates to enhance functionality without hardware replacement.
- 210: Not supported (fixed firmware).
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported via Flash memory updates.
- Internal MPU Watchdog
- Definition: Monitors the internal Microprocessor Unit (MPU) for errors and restarts the system if a fault occurs.
- All models: Supported.
- Datakey Configuration Support
- Definition: Replaces traditional program cards and DIP switches with a removable Datakey containing non-volatile memory for configuration storage.
- 210, 2010ECL, 2018ECL: Not supported (uses DIP switches or program cards).
- 2018KCL: Supported.
- LED Field Signal Monitoring (LEDguard®)
- Definition: Optimizes monitoring for LED signal loads, which have different electrical characteristics compared to incandescent signals.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
Fault Monitoring Enhancements
- Red Failure Monitoring
- Definition: Detects when no Red signal is present on a channel, preventing dark intersections.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
- Dual Indication Monitoring
- Definition: Detects when two different color signals (e.g., Green and Yellow, Yellow and Red) are active on the same channel simultaneously.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
- Clearance Monitoring
- Definition: Detects missing Yellow Clearance Interval between Green and Red signals to prevent immediate Red after Green.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
- AC Line Brown-Out Detection
- Definition: Detects low AC voltage and prevents false triggering of faults.
- All models: Supported.
- Recurrent Pulse Detection
- Definition: Identifies intermittent signal failures that occur in short pulses and might be missed by standard monitoring.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
- Flashing Yellow Arrow (FYA) Support
- Definition: Supports Flashing Yellow Arrow (FYA) Mode, ensuring correct operation in intersections with protected-permissive phasing.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
Communication & Interface
- Serial Communication Port (EIA-232)
- Definition: Allows connection to a PC or controller for event logging and remote diagnostics.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
- Ethernet Communication (IP Models Only)
- Definition: Provides remote access and diagnostics over a network.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECLip, 2018ECLip, 2018KCLip: Supported.
- Diagnostic Display Mode
- Definition: Displays real-time signal conditions and fault states for troubleshooting.
- 210: Basic fault display.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Advanced diagnostic display.
- Event Logging
- Definition: Stores fault logs and channel status history for later analysis.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
Installation & Programming
- Program Card-Based Configuration
- Definition: Uses a diode-based program card to configure channel assignments and conflict settings.
- 210, 2010ECL, 2018ECL: Supported.
- 2018KCL: Not supported (uses Datakey instead).
- DIP Switch Configuration
- Definition: Allows manual configuration of settings via DIP switches.
- 210, 2010ECL, 2018ECL: Supported.
- 2018KCL: Not supported (uses Datakey instead).
- Remote Configuration Support
- Definition: Allows remote modification and monitoring using a PC or network.
- 210: Not supported.
- 2010ECL, 2018ECL, 2018KCL: Supported.
For more information on a comparison between the signal monitors, please see our article here.